Compare three Indianapolis roofers: a family company roofing the city since 1939 with a transferable lifetime labor warranty, a north-side shop for homes with flat sections and commercial roofs, and a women-owned south-side crew that works in English and Spanish.
Independently vetted by The Roofers Guide · Updated November 4, 2026 · How we vet →
| Roofer | Homeowner rating | Years | BBB | Workmanship warranty | Best for | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1WaterTight Roofing & Exteriors | 4.9★ (166) | 87 | A+ | — | Best for a family company roofing Indy since 1939 | View profile |
| 2Two Brothers Roofing | 4.9★ (109) | 14 | A+ | — | Best for homes with a flat or low-slope section | View profile |
| 3Martinez Roofing & More | 5.0★ (46) | 2 | A | — | Best for a small, women-owned crew on the south side | View profile |
Rather not call around? Tell us about your project once and we’ll get up to 3 quotes from these roofers for you. Get my free quotes →
Every company here passed the same independent editorial screen. We reviewed its operating presence, public reputation, business history, relevant registrations, and traceable credentials. We also explain what distinguishes each roofer so you can match the shortlist to your project.
A family-owned Indianapolis roofing company that has served the city since 1939, led by Richard Hathaway Jr.
A north-side Indianapolis roofing company led by Dana LaLiberte that handles both shingle roofs for homes and flat roofs and coatings for commercial buildings, plus seamless gutters, across Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, and Noblesville.
A family-run, women-owned roofing company on the south side of Indianapolis, led by Jacqueline Hall, that replaces and repairs shingle roofs, fixes flashing and ventilation, and works in English and Spanish from Perry Township out to Greenwood and Franklin.
What a new roof runs for a typical single-family home in Indianapolis before insurance. Standing-seam metal runs higher. The number moves with your roof’s size and pitch and how much decking has to be replaced once the old layers come off.
Hired one of these contractors and got burned? Worked for one and saw something off? Heard something from a neighbor that didn’t add up? Tips feed our research process — we investigate every substantive one. They aren’t published as public reviews.
Send a tip →The storm history, how Indiana licenses roofers, and the questions we ask any Indianapolis contractor before we feature them.
How we picked Indianapolis's roofers
The local fact to know
Our city pages rank for “roofers in [city]” and the searches around them. A homeowner can request your shop directly, or ask us to coordinate up to three quotes while keeping their phone number and email private.
